Categories
Article

The Differences Between Issuing Bonds and Sukuk Under Omani Law

In Oman, the issuance of bonds and sukuk is regulated predominantly under the Regulation Governing Bonds and Sukuk, issued by the Capital Market Authority, whose functions passed days later to the Financial Services Authority under Royal Decree 20/2024. The regulation does not apply to government (sovereign) bonds and sukuk, as they are governed by the Public Debt Law. Bonds and sukuk are both means of raising capital, but the regulation draws clear distinctions between them. This blog, therefore, explores the differences between both instruments issued under the Regulation Governing Bonds and Sukuk: their legal nature, the assets behind them, how they are structured and supervised, and the requirements they share.

Legal Nature

Article 1(4) of the regulation defines bonds as “financial securities of equal value issued for a specified period by the issuer in the form of a debt instrument or obligation, through which the issuer undertakes to pay the value of the bond upon redemption (if any) with a periodical return to its holder throughout the issue period”. In this context, a bond creates a direct creditor-debtor relationship. The bondholder is entitled to repayment of the principal, usually at maturity, alongside periodic payments during the life of the bond, but has no ownership of any of the issuer’s assets.

Article 1(5) defines sukuk as “financial securities of equal value issued for a specified period by the beneficiary through a special purpose vehicle, representing a joint stake in the ownership of underlying assets, services, rights, or a combination of them or in the assets of a specific project, an existing investment activity, or one which will be established from the proceeds of the subscription, through which the beneficiary undertakes to pay the value of the sukuk upon redemption (if any) with a periodical return to its owner throughout the issue period”. Unlike a bondholder, a sukukholder is not a creditor but a co-owner, holding an undivided share in what the sukuk represent. The definition also allows that ownership relate to a project or activity yet to be established from the subscription proceeds, so sukuk may be used to finance it from the outset.

The Periodical Return

Both definitions describe the payment made during the issue period as a “periodical return”; what the return consists of depends on the nature of each instrument. In practice, the return on a bond is known as “interest”, which is a payment received at regular intervals at either a fixed rate or a rate that moves with the market. The return on sukuk, by contrast, is considered “profit” or “rent” generated by the assets, services, rights or project that the sukuk represent. This distinction between debt and ownership partially explains why the regulation treats the two instruments differently. Because a bond involves no ownership, the regulation need only govern the debt itself; sukuk represent ownership rather than debt, so the regulation must specify who holds what the sukukholders jointly own and ensure compliance with Sharia.

Issuance Structure and the Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV)

Bonds may be issued directly by the issuer. Under article 1(6), the term “issuer” covers joint stock companies, limited liability companies, investment funds, special purpose vehicles, and any other issuer of bonds approved by the authority. Article 1(8) defines an SPV as an entity with its own legal personality and independent financial liability (article 47), formed specifically to issue bonds or sukuk “in favour of the issuer or beneficiary and licensed to do so by the authority”. An SPV is therefore permitted for bonds but not required. Alternatively, a sukuk issuance structure comprises two parties: the beneficiary (al-mustafid), which is the sukuk equivalent of a bond’s issuer, and an SPV. For sukuk, the SPV is mandatory; article 34 requires the SPV to issue them for the beneficiary under a Sharia-compliant “issue contract”.

Under article 52(4), the SPV may own or keep assets “in favour of bondholders or sukukholders”. Although article 1(8) provides that an SPV “may be entrusted with carrying out the trust activity”, and article 52(8) lists this among its functions, the assets may instead be held through a financial trust under chapter six. Accordingly, the SPV need not hold the assets itself. In a trust, the beneficiary acts as a settlor and places the assets in the care of a separate trustee for the benefit of the holders. This is contingent, however, on the trustee being a securities company licensed to act as the holders’ agent, and it is “appointed by the issuer or beneficiary”. In either case, the SPV remains the entity that issues the sukuk. It is also important to note that trusts are not limited to sukuk; they may be used in a bond issuance, since the settlor may be “the beneficiary or the issuer”. Even so, the difference is that a bond issuance may use these structures, whereas a sukuk issuance must always be made through an SPV, with assets held either by the SPV or through a trust.

Sharia Compliance

Conventional bonds are not subject to Sharia compliance obligations and Sharia supervisory review. Alternatively, sukuk must comply with Sharia principles from issuance and throughout their life, as Sharia is built into the structure itself. Compliance is then checked at three stages:

Before issuance: the prospectus approval process for sukuk requires the issue manager to supply the authority with a certificate issued by the committee confirming that the issuance is compliant with Islamic Sharia principles.

Supervision: under article 71, the beneficiary must ensure compliance in one of three ways: establishing a dedicated committee to supervise Sharia compliance, using its own existing committee, or contracting with a specialist Sharia supervision firm or an entity that has an in-house Sharia committee. Any newly established committee must comprise an odd number of, at least three, duly qualified members, and should decide matters by majority vote. Whichever route is chosen, the Sharia supervisors must be left to work independently; neither the beneficiary nor the SPV may influence their work, and both are obliged to cooperate with them by allowing them full access to relevant documents relating to the issuance.

Every year: under article 82, the beneficiary must publish a yearly report proving the compliance of the sukuk with the provisions of Islamic Sharia.

What Bonds and Sukuk Have in Common

Despite the mentioned differences, the regulation applies the same procedural safeguards to both instruments:

  • Listing: both are required to be listed on the Muscat Stock Exchange.
  • Prospectus and issue manager: both require a licensed issue manager and a prospectus approved by the authority.
  • Credit rating: whenever bonds or sukuk are issued, or if the maturity date is pushed back, a credit rating certificate is required for public and preferential right offerings, where the issuer or beneficiary has lost part of its capital, or in other situations at the authority’s discretion, and the rating must be maintained until maturity.
  • Disclosure: both are required to disclose material information without delay.
  • Investor protection: both require a licensed agent to represent the holders, who must be independent, with no connection to or interest in the issuer or beneficiary. Both also require a general meeting of holders.

Conclusion

The regulation brings bonds and sukuk under a single framework, but it does not treat them as the same instrument. The key distinction is between debt and ownership: a bondholder is a creditor of the issuer, while a sukukholder owns a joint share in what the sukuk represent. Due to this joint ownership, sukuk must be issued through an SPV under a Sharia-compliant contract, and they remain under Sharia supervision from before issuance until redemption. Beyond these differences, both instruments share the same requirements on listing, prospectuses, ratings, disclosure, and investor protection.

If you are interested in this topic, we highly recommend you read this regulation in full at the link below: